Umbrella Academy: What Happened to Ben?
April 4, 2019 | News | No Comments
This story contains spoilers for The Umbrella Academy comics and Netflix series.
With word coming that The Umbrella Academy has been renewed for a second season, we thought it would be worth revisiting some of our more popular stories about Season 1.
For more on Umbrella Academy, check out our Ending Explained feature here. Or learn all about the Umbrella Academy comics here!
Whether you’re watching the Netflix show or reading the comics, Umbrella Academy fans are dying to know the answer to one burning question: what happened to Ben Hargreeves AKA Number 6 AKA The Horror. We know he’s dead, but how?
An Unhappy Child
In the comics, the flashback scenes we do see of Ben show whipping tentacles emerging from his stomach, and we get a sense that he’s insanely powerful, but we really get no insight into what kind of personality he had as a young child.
Sir Reginald Hargreeves does mention in a personal note in the comics that #6 is “easily manipulated due to enthusiastic if naive nature.” And in Vanya’s book, she writes about The Horror, calling him “the kindest of my siblings, but he was so eager to please Father. He was easily manipulated, dragged into Father and Luther’s little games — and those two simply let him die.”
Error 429 Mashing buttons will get you nowhere!
Mashing buttons will get you nowhere!
Guru Meditation:
XID: 267846465
Varnish cache server
Dr. Pogo reveals in Apocalypse Suite #5 in a diary excerpt, written during the children’s late teen years (prior to the death of The Horror) that, “None of the children want to be heroes, and none less than The Horror [00.06]. He’s only trying to please Hargreeves and Spaceboy. I suppose this is normal enough for a teenage human, but he’s not learning how to be an individual in his own right.”
We do see more of Ben’s personality displayed in the show. In flashbacks, he seems like a sad kid, reluctant to be a part of this crime-fighting team. In episode 1, we see the young Umbrella Academy respond to a bank robbery. It’s obvious that Ben does not want any part of this, but his brother #1 Luther persists. Begrudgingly, Ben goes in. And the shadows speak volumes. You hear screams, see people getting flung around, and blood splattered everywhere.
After foiling the bank robbery, the other Umbrella Academy members stand before the press beaming with pride, while Ben seems disengaged.
There’s not much to go on, so let’s really read into this. In the beginning of episode 1, we can see notes on Sir Reginald Hargreeves desk and it clearly says “Number 6 — seems to be angry” It’s hard to make out that last word, but even the rigid, emotionless Sir Hargreeves could see Ben was unhappy.
You may remember, in the comics, Pogo says none of the kids want to be heroes, but in the show, we see a different story. Besides Ben and Klaus, the rest of the Umbrella Academy seemed thrilled about using their powers and fighting crime during their childhood.
\r\nTalk about killer art! Velvet Buzzsaw is a satirical thriller set in the contemporary art world scene of Los Angeles, where supernatural force enacts revenge on those who have allowed their greed to get in the way of art. From Nightcrawler\u0027s Dan Gilroy, and starring Jake Gyllenhaal, Rene Russo, Toni Collette, and John Malkovich.”,”height”:2400,”width”:3600,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/velvet-buzzsaw-001-1548258142748.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/velvet-buzzsaw-001-1548258142748_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:”02″,”albumTotalCount”:11},{“caption”:”RAY ROMANO: RIGHT HERE, AROUND THE CORNER (Special Available 2\/5\/19)
\r\n23 years after his last stand-up special, comedian, screenwriter, and Emmy Award-winning actor Ray Romano debuts his first Netflix comedy special. Performing two sets on the same night – one at Manhattan\u2019s Comedy Cellar and the second at the Village Underground, literally around the corner.”,”height”:2160,”width”:3234,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/1502446-311582-1548259899825.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/1502446-311582-1548259899825_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:”03″,”albumTotalCount”:11},{“caption”:”ONE DAY AT A TIME: SEASON 3 (Series Available 2\/8\/19)
\r\nPenelope studies to become a nurse practitioner, Elena and Syd grow closer, Alex gets punished, Lydia tackles a bucket list, and Schneider falls in love”,”height”:3006,”width”:4500,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/odaat-307-unit-00341r-1548259411702.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/odaat-307-unit-00341r-1548259411702_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:”04″,”albumTotalCount”:11},{“caption”:”HIGH FLYING BIRD (Movie Available 2\/8\/19)
\r\nDirected by Steven Soderbergh, High Flying Bird tells the story of sports agent Ray Burke (Andr\u00e9 Holland), who finds himself caught in the face-off between the league and the players. Also starring Zazie Beetz, Melvin Gregg, Zachary Quinto, Kyle MacLachlan and Bill Duke.”,”height”:1606,”width”:2404,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/high-flying-bird-08-1548262210380.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/high-flying-bird-08-1548262210380_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:”05″,”albumTotalCount”:11},{“caption”:”KEVIN HART\u0027S GUIDE TO BLACK HISTORY (Special Available 2\/8\/19)
\r\nIn this 1+ hour comedic special, Kevin Hart plays himself while discussing the fascinating contributions of lesser known individuals from Black history through the lens of various educational reenactments.”,”height”:1080,”width”:1617,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/4848de60-d97b-11e8-b627-0e319b527290-1548260644143.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/4848de60-d97b-11e8-b627-0e319b527290-1548260644143_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:”06″,”albumTotalCount”:11},{“caption”:”KEN JEONG: YOU COMPLETE ME, HO (Special Available 2\/14\/19)
\r\nComedian, actor and former physician Ken Jeong returns to his stand-up roots for his first-ever Netflix comedy special as Jeong reflects on how he went from being a doctor to a comedy superstar and opens up about how his wife\u2019s courageous battle with breast cancer led to him starring in one of the biggest comedy franchises of all time, The Hangover”,”height”:2160,”width”:3234,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/1513723-585272201-1548259902440.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/1513723-585272201-1548259902440_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:”07″,”albumTotalCount”:11},{“caption”:”THE UMBRELLA ACADEMY (Series Available 2\/15\/19)
\r\nReunited by their father\u0027s death, estranged siblings with extraordinary powers uncover shocking family secrets — and a looming threat to humanity. The Umbrella Academy is based on the popular, Eisner award-winning comics and graphic novels created and written by Gerard Way (My Chemical Romance), illustrated by Gabriel B\u00e1, and published by Dark Horse Comics. It stars Ellen Paige, Mary J. Blige, Kate Walsh, Tom Hopper, and Robert Sheehan.”,”height”:2160,”width”:3233,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/storyart-5000×2813-template-noui-rb02-1548262073068.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/storyart-5000×2813-template-noui-rb02-1548262073068_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:”08″,”albumTotalCount”:11},{“caption”:”THE DRAGON PRINCE: SEASON 2 (Series Available 2\/15\/19)
\r\nRayla and the princes hurry toward Xadia with their precious cargo. But Claudia and Soren are close behind — and determined to stop them.”,”height”:1152,”width”:1725,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/billboard-dark-na-zxx-01-1548259896301.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/billboard-dark-na-zxx-01-1548259896301_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:”09″,”albumTotalCount”:11},{“caption”:”PADDLETON (Movie Available 2\/22\/19)
\r\n An unlikely friendship between two misfit neighbors becomes an unexpectedly emotional journey when the younger man is diagnosed with terminal cancer. Starring Mark Duplass, Ray Romano, Ravi Patel and Christine Woods.”,”height”:1333,”width”:2500,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/22\/paddleton-filmframe-00001-1548170892909.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/22\/paddleton-filmframe-00001-1548170892909_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:10,”albumTotalCount”:11},{“caption”:”WORKIN\u0027 MOMS (Series Available 2\/22\/19)\r\nAn original comedy series created by and starring Catherine Reitman that tests the modern ideal that women really can have it all.”,”height”:1080,”width”:1616,”url”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/707038c0-f7ee-11e8-bf80-12a3b43f6fe4-1548260314677.jpg”,”styleUrl”:”https:\/\/assets1.ignimgs.com\/2019\/01\/23\/707038c0-f7ee-11e8-bf80-12a3b43f6fe4-1548260314677_{size}.jpg”,”credit”:””,”objectRelationName”:””,”objectRelationUrl”:””,”albumName”:”Netflix Spotlight: February 2019″,”relativePosition”:11,”albumTotalCount”:11}]’
data-ads-disabled=’false’
data-ad-frequency=’3′
data-image-size=’1280w’>
A sad, troubled child, extremely eager to please his father and brother, with a giant monster within him, that he’s internally conflicted about — sounds like a recipe for disaster.
From Pogo’s analysis and what we have seen, we can conclude that Ben wasn’t happy with himself or his situation. If your heart is not in something, you will not be performing at 100%. A half-hearted Ben could have had a tragic slip up that led to his demise.
The show drops hints about Ben’s death throughout the first episode. In the flashing family photos as the team ages, we see Ben eventually disappear. We also see a statue built in Ben’s honor with a plaque below grimly inscribed with:
“May the darkness within you find peace in the light.”
Who’s Responsible for Ben’s Death?
So what happened to Ben? We really have little to go on here. In the second issue of Umbrella Academy: Apocalypse Suite, we learn that #1 Luther AKA Spaceboy feels responsible or at least some guilt for what happened to Ben.
He’s seen with #3 Allison AKA The Rumor in front of Ben’s statue, and she says: “It wasn’t your fault, you know. I know everyone blames you for what happened to Ben. But none of us knows what really happened that day.”
Luther quickly changes the topic. And if you think that’s out of callousness, maybe not. In the comics, Luther has a robot assistant when he’s in space. The robot’s name? Ben. Perhaps Luther is paying homage to his fallen brother, trying to preserve his memory — or maybe it’s a chilling reminder of what went wrong that day, so it will never happen again.
In the comics and the show, Ben’s statue is not a child. The statue looks like a young man. And since Ben’s ghost in the show is an adult, that further backs that idea.
Error 429 Mashing buttons will get you nowhere!
Mashing buttons will get you nowhere!
Guru Meditation:
XID: 267846466
Varnish cache server
We don’t see this exact scene between Luther and Allison play out in the show… but it is interesting to point out that in episode 1 when Luther and Diego (AKA #2, The Kraken) are fighting, Luther throws a punch at Diego and Luther accidentally knocks Ben’s statue off its pedestal and the head cracks off.
Luther (in the show and comics) is the de facto leader of the group. And in the first episode, it is Luther telling Ben to go into the vault. We can assume most of their missions went down like this, with Luther pushing Ben to take action that he probably did not want to.
Luther may have ordered Ben to do something that ended up taking his life. Or did Ben finally fight back with some sad result? Did Ben flee and fall into some trouble? What did Luther do? We posed this question to Umbrella Academy creator Gerard Way, and he teased that Luther may not be entirely to blame:
“I think that they all maybe have some involvement in his death,” said Way.
That changes things quite a bit. Knowing that everyone shoulders the blame for Ben’s death means that it might not be solely Luther’s fault. It could be that #1 simply feels the most responsible because he’s the team leader.
Unlike the comics, we actually get to see Ben’s ghost in the show, talking with Klaus quite a bit. Ben is kind of like Klaus’s Jiminy Cricket, trying to keep him on the straight and narrow.
When Ben is talking to Klaus, we don’t see any injuries or visible trauma. In episode 4, when Klaus talked to the dead while kidnapped by Cha-Cha and Hazel, it’s quite apparent how those people were killed. But who knows, maybe Ben’s clothing is hiding some monstrous wound we just can’t see.
Error 429 Mashing buttons will get you nowhere!
Mashing buttons will get you nowhere!
Guru Meditation:
XID: 267846467
Varnish cache server
For now, the biggest clue to take away here is that perhaps the whole family was involved in Ben’s death, and whatever happened to him, it doesn’t seem like he was taken out in a traditional way. We are talking about Umbrella Academy here, with time travel, mind control, superpowers, the gamut. Ben’s cause of death seems far from normal.
But when we asked Way what actually happened to Ben, the creator remained tight-lipped. “I’m not even quite sure if I could reveal that. That’s beyond a spoiler because it has to do with the comic too and it hasn’t been revealed in the comic,” Way told IGN.
“I don’t even know what happened to Ben!” Umbrella Academy showrunner Steve Blackman admitted. So, stay tuned for a future season?
Any theories on what happened to Ben? Tell us in the comments section. And don’t forget to check out our review of The Umbrella Academy Season 1 and our Umbrella Academy explainer.
Jacki Jing is an Amazonian Super Hero Ninja wannabe by moonlight and a host/producer for IGN by daylight. Anime’s her jam and Tuxedo Mask is her main man — him, or Batman. Follow her on Twitter at @jackijing.